A salesperson was hired at ₹48 lakh cost to company (CTC). By month nine he had booked ₹0, and he was let go. But he had done nothing wrong.
CTC
booked by month 9
He had done nothing wrong.
Same industry, a completely different buying process
He had 12 years of banking, financial services and insurance (BFSI) sales on his CV. The hiring brief said "BFSI experience mandatory". He had it.
Core banking software to CIOs
Through request-for-proposal (RFP) processes, 18-month cycles and L1 (lowest-bid) evaluations.
A sale to business heads
Through a 6-week proof of concept (POC), signed by a regional head, not the CIO.
The industry was the same. The buying process was not.
What the wrong filter cost
₹36 lakh in fixed salary. Nine months of an empty territory. And a good salesperson walking out believing he had failed.
The mistake was never his. It was in how the hiring brief defined fit
Industry experience tells you who he knows, not how he sells
Industry experience feels like the safe hire. It tells you who he knows. It does not tell you how he sells. What predicts the first order is the buying process he has already won in.
Four questions about his last three deals
Interview Questions
Who signed the PO, and what was their title?
The role of the final signatory, not just the name.
How was it evaluated?
A proof of concept, a request for proposal, or the founder's call.
How many weeks from first meeting to PO?
The real cycle, not the one on the CV.
Who else had to say yes?
The size of the buying group.
If his answers sound like your last ten closed deals, he will reach his first order faster, even if he has never sold in your industry.
When I would still hire for industry
The buyer community is small and closed
Regulation decides the deal, not the user
The first year's pipeline depends on who he already knows
Outside those cases, industry experience is a tiebreaker, not a filter.
Related: Your sales interview tests for the job they used to have — the zero-support deal test for senior hires.
Related: Five months in, no closures. Did you hire the wrong salesperson? — how long a new salesperson really takes to reach a first order.